Class of 2021
- Jacob Haaksma (Biola University)
- Jordan Bergsma 2020-22 (Calvin)
- Corey Campbell 2020-22 (Calvin)
- Will Gelderloos 2020-22 (Calvin)
- Lucas Oezer 2020-21 (Calvin)
- Julien Camy 2019-22 (Calvin)
- Jake Boender 2018-19 (Calvin)
- Tim Randall 2016-20 (Calvin)
- Justin Bart 2016-18 (Delta State University)
- Matt VanHarn 2013 (Calvin)
- Mitchell Schroder 2013-16 (Calvin)
- Troy VanPortfliet 2013-16 (Hope)
- Tyler Ligon 2013 (Calvin)
- Andrew VanderLei 2012-15 (Calvin)
- Grant Ludema 2012-15 (Hope)
- Wesley Keeton Tatum 2012-15 (Whitworth University)
- Erik Arent 2011-14 (Ohio Northern)
- Geoff Ludema 2010-13 (Hope)
- Lucas Seebeck (Calvin)
- Brian Dekorne (Calvin)
- Brad Flikkema (Calvin)
- Derek VanderHeide 1994-1997 (Hope) NCAA D3 All-American (Honorable Mention)
- Russ Dekker (Eastern Michigan)
- Matt Hollebeek (Hope)
- Dirk Pruis (Calvin)